Hardware Review
Logitech TrackMan Wheel
Developer: Logitech
Price: $30 (corded); $50 (cordless)
Requirements: Mac or PC with USB
Trial: None
There are many multi-button input devices to choose from, but when it comes to mice there isn’t much difference between one model and the next—at the end of the day, they all leave users with stiff joints and wrist pain from repetitive movements and stress. For many users, the Logitech TrackMan Wheel can offer significant relief from repetitive stress aches and pains by providing superior ergonomics. Instead of moving the hand and wrist as is typical with mouse control, the hand and wrist are stationary when using the TrackMan. The user’s thumb rotates the trackball to control the cursor, and the remaining fingers can be used for the buttons or scroll wheel.
Installation is simple and pleasant. With the corded model, plug the cord into an available USB port. With the wireless model, plug the USB radio dongle into an available USB port, and make sure the AA battery is installed into the TrackMan. Logitech chose to use a proprietary radio dongle over Bluetooth. Using their own system ensures compatibility with Macs that do not have Bluetooth, however it also uses an additional USB port and duplicates technology already available on Bluetooth-equipped Macs. The device becomes instantly available without further installation, but Logitech provides additional drivers that allow programmable scrolling, application switching, and keystroke shortcuts.
The TrackMan Wheel requires only finger and thumb movements, so it requires little desk space. Because the device works independently of the surface it is used on, the TrackMan Wheel can even be used almost anywhere (even in your lap) with no problems.
The trackball moves smoothly under the thumb, and the resulting cursor actions are equally smooth and precise. The tracking is precise enough to make text selection easy, even in the first few minutes of use. The buttons offer feedback, both with an auditory click and noticeable movement. The scroll wheel has a rubberized coating, offering a tactile separation from the plastic buttons surrounding it. Using the scroll wheel as a button was a little mushier than expected, but still adequate.
The TrackMan Wheel may take a few hours to get used to. After years of practice, most people automatically try to pickup the TrackMan and move it the same way they would a mouse. This old habit completely disappears after a few days of retraining.
The only thing I would like to be improved about the TrackMan Wheel is the appearance. In my opinion, the gray-metallic-plastic and maroon speckled trackball are not a pleasant combination; it’s reminiscent of the cheap plastic telescopes and science kits available at the local toy store. Something less techno-kitsch would be welcome.
Results
I tested the TrackMan with word processing, graphics, 3D, games, and video editing applications. The device performed admirably in all, and was surprisingly easy to use for precise tasks. This is not only due to the precision of the device, but because during mouse-clicking the cursor will remain stationary even if the entire TrackMan moves—unlike with a mouse. While the TrackMan works for games, it doesn’t offer the solidity or ergonomic options necessary for hard-core game use. Other trackball controllers are better suited for anything more than casual gaming.
Overall, I recommend the Logitech TrackMan Wheel, especially for older users who suffer from aches due to repetitive mouse use.
Copyright © 2005 Andrew Kator, akator@atpm.com. Reviewing in
ATPM is open to anyone. If you’re interested, write to us at
reviews@atpm.com.
Reader Comments (15)
There are a couple of other points that you didn't get around to.
A trackball is a much more accurate tool for graphics work than a mouse. It won't replace a tablet but is adequate for mobile work in places where even a small tablet would be inappropriate or unusable.
I have the cordless vesion and find it excellent for presentations. Since it doesn't need a good mousing surface, I can walk around while talking and still advance slides or use the pointer.
On the down side, while this product is excellent for most people, it is a bit small for people with large hands or for left-handers.
I know many a first-person gamer that are using the TrackMan device for gaming. In fact, they are superior in many FPS games for the quick response you can get with just the flick of the thumb. The only thing that would make it better is if the ball accepted faster movements - maybe Logitech should consider a gaming version of the TrackMan?
This is a great product.
Removing the ball, cleaning the nubs, and replacing the ball can be done in just ten or fifteen seconds.
To clean, turn upside down and gently but firmly smack it down on the palm of your other hand. The ball pops right out. I clean mine with a microfiber cloth designed for lenses. You can wash the ball if it gets grungy but be sure it's good and dry before putting back in. Be careful not to pop out the little teflon balls that the thumb ball glides on. It's easy to put them back in but also easy to loose them!
I also keep thumb balls from old mice for swapping out if my current ball has a problem. As long as they are in good shape they can be reused to replace a damaged or clammy ball.
Another trick... it you spend so much time using the mouse intensely (like gaming) that your palm starts to get sore from pressure on the hard plastic get a small gel insert for high heels and pad the top. That is one thing I would change about this mouse, to have a soft insert on the top.
It does two things - it collects lots of grime and needs to be changed every few months, or in a pinch, just pull off the dirty tuft of the top layer and replace.
The other is that it steadies the ball for more precise movement without affecting normal use.
Also, at my dentist's office, the receptionist had her arm in a sling and was in great pain. I asked her what was up. She said her wrist was getting worse and worse and she was scheduled for an operation for carpel tunnel.
I immediately went out to a computer store nearby, no longer there, and bought this Trackman. She was concerned that others use the mouse. I told her both could be attached, and anyone could use what they want. She tried it and had some difficulty with orienting up and down.
I asked her to stay with it for a week. I told her she would get used to it. She did. And then for a month. And has been happily using it for many years. And never needed that operation!
My 2 cents.
Add A Comment